The Paradox Between Education and Enlightenment: The Practical Impasse in Kant's Thought of Education
-
摘要: 在康德的教育思想思路中,人的成长分两步走:首先,从任性无序到有序生存;其次,在有序生存中走向道德法则的建立。人的任性生存是一种无序状态,需要通过教育来压制人的任性,把一种行为准则强加在他身上。教育是对自由的限制,是要在人的生存中造就一种在准则中生存的习惯,从而让人的自由能够在一种秩序中运作。因此,教育是启蒙的起点。康德在分析教育活动时感受到了教育(外在力量)与启蒙(内在力量)之间的张力,并认为这个张力是人成长的主要推动力。成人之后,人就能够在自由中不断完善自身,而教育作为自由的压制者就不再起作用了。然而,深入分析表明,缺失了教育与启蒙之间的张力,仅仅依靠人的自由,道德完善过程是无法实现的。在这个意义上,康德的教育思想在实践上是不完整的。Abstract: In Kant's educational thought, he observes two steps in one's reaching adulthood, that is, through being wayward and disorderly to disciplined, and then from which establishing moral laws. One lives waywardly, which is a disorderly state. It is therefore necessary to discipline him through education by imposing a code of conduct on him. Education limits his freedom to create the habit of living in people's lives so as to let one to perform one's freedom in a certain behavior pattern. In this point of view, education is the starting point of enlightenment. When analyzing educational activities, Kant feels the paradox of education (the external power) and enlightenment (the internal power), and he conceives this paradox as the major dynamical power in one's reaching adulthood. Yet, when one has obtained adulthood, one will be able to improve oneself in freedom alone and no longer need external intervention by education which is regarded as a free register. However, through an in-depth analysis, one will then be unable to accomplish morality in practice only by the freedom of people, without the paradox of education and enlightenment. In this observation, Kant's religious thought is incomplete in practice.
-
Key words:
- Kant /
- Education /
- Freedom /
- Enlightenment /
- Morality
-
[1] 康德. 教育学[A]李秋零译注. 康德教育哲学文集[C]. 中国人民大学出版社, 2016: 8. [2] 康德. 单纯理性界限内的宗教[M]. 李秋零, 译. 中国人民大学出版社, 2003: 13.
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 8
- HTML全文浏览量: 10
- PDF下载量: 0
- 被引次数: 0